IMO Girard

Girard.

Girard has more value because of his contract. But whose better is very close.

It’s close but I think girard, and with his contract term being longer he should hold more value

Girard imo

Sergachev is better for tampa imo cause he can effectively play both sides. Rutta is marked down as the 1st RD but he really splits time with Sergachev up there so Rutta only really plays 11 mins a game. Hedman's good enough to carry anyone really (Rutta, Schenn, Bogosian) thus it keeps costs low, and really during important moments he's playing with Sergachev

Girard can play both sides as well

That's a big bonus for Girard then. Iunno i might be bias but just the combination of size, speed and skill with Sergachev. Girard might be the better overall player rn but I'd bet on Sergachev becoming one of the better D-men in the league at some point in his development.

Agreed but Girard before cooling off late was having a norris caliber season in his own right

Girard's contract gives him a lot of value and he's probably better right now, but I wouldn't be surprised if when they're both at their peaks Sergachev is better