I definitely think that gets it done. Not sure if NJ should do it unless they are real confident in their other young guys.

Agree.
Beats anything recent from Rangers.

I don't know about definitely but it's a solid offer. I would do it

I think it's a solid offer but it won't happen

Eichel might not seem like the best fit right now but he'll still be young in 2-3 years when NJ should be competitive. him and Hughes down the middle would be so sweet

Good Title...

Two things...IF Buff is going to get rid of Eichel then IMO:
a) They go for it 110% by finding a dance partner/pidgeon that'll take Skinner too, and
b) BUFF is dead last in all things "Goalie/Goals-Against/D-Fence" stat-wise so that'll likely be a major ask back of that "#1G-man Starter &/or #1/#2 D-man"...

doubt it. adding Skinner to the deal would significantly worsen the return

Yeah, I'm not saying NJ is in the running then unless the assets match BUFF needs - it'll be someone else willing to do it maybe?
* A good GM w/ BUFF will float the absolute worst tasting tonic-cr*p to his opposing GMs first. It's what you do...