Saskoiler for now
Rejoint: avr. 2020
Messages: 13,357
Mentions "j'aime": 9,283
Here is a run down of every trade for you, because there's a lot to dissect here.
Wpg: Not a chance. You don't give up your franchise dman for a late first if you are contending. Just no.
Edm: If Edmonton does it, why not. Kerfoot is easily expendable. If the leafs are offered a second rounder for him, they must do it.
Phi: Meh, I guess, but swaps like this don't just happen for no reason at all. Won't happen.
Det: I think the value is there. Not sure if Detroit wants to deal Bertuzzi though. He's almost like their Zach Hyman.
Buf: What is the point of this one? People roast Toronto's defense and then turn around and deal top 4 defenseman away for free (Engvall is at least worth the 6th by himself)? Why does this benefit the leafs in any way? It doesn't even suit Buffalo's needs anyway, they are rebuilding, but I'm sure they'd be happy to have a free Justin Holl, just some team would offer more if Holl was available (he's not though).
Clb: Why? He's an effective defensive forward. Why sell him off for cheap just get someone else? Especially since he's probably worth more than this deal.
All in all not horrible, but just not realistic and isn't a good idea for reasons mentioned above.