I hate to be that guy but Evans isn't technically a rookie since he played 13 games last year.
lines start to get blurred on guys like that.
I don't know. Some guys totally deserving here as they are not "prospects" anymore.
Others still probably fall into that category. Like POJ for the penguins. He keeps getting benched. He's on his way back down to wbs and he probably should have never been called up, only was because of so many injuries. He's clearly still a prospect at this point.
The 4 goalies he listed have been better & have started the majority of their team's games through this point in the season. He's got the right 4 goalies up here.