None of these teams would accept these trades from Boston. It's super rare for an offer sheet to actually work so we're not getting Mantha.

Why are you talking about offersheet ?? I haven’t done one, I trade for his rights

Detroit passes they like Mantha and have no interest in Kase if it means trading Mantha.

You forgot beecher, debrusk and mcavoy in the mantha trade

Kase and a late 1st round pick is nowhere near Anthony Manrha's value.

Try DeBrusk and Carlo as starters for Mantha, Yes that offer was that bad.

I get mantha HAD value, he always have big hope and doesn’t show

Yeah you offer us a player that's not even remotely close to getting Mantha plus a late 1st round pick. Any deal for Mantha probably starts with Jake DeBrusk and possibly Carlo.

The Blues say a firm no thanks.

Kase best season 38 points Mantha 2 48 points and a 38 point season on a shortened 71 game season. Yean no thanks you can keep Kase.

Mantha isn't worth anywhere near an elite number 1 d-man

Kase just sucks, he's not good at all. Decent 3rd liner and excellent 4th liner IMO

Yeah Dunn is very underrated IMO, keep him, even if it means moving a Sundqvist

I'd imagine neither will be going anywhere unless Army suddenly goes galaxy brain.

If we're lucky possibly something based around DeBrusk and Carlo, But yeah McAvoy would be a major pipedream.

They just aren't looking to trade mantha. Now if boston put studnicka in a deal it might get a bit more of a look. Thats the real position of need that could get Detroit interested.

If you want McAvoy with Mantha included, then add Seider. Simple as that

Agreed, McAvoy would easily cost Larkin. And Yzerman already said that Larkin is pretty much untouchable and the future team will evolve around him.

Right and mantha is worth way more then what the poster put, I will always counter with the same that the poster puts when it's way under. Mcavoy for mantha straight up isn't that for of a stretch to be fair, the other pieces put it in ridiculous mode

Mantha for Kase? I don't understand why Detroit would accept that at ALL

You're right, I didn't notice. Regardless, that trade would never happen. Detroit loves Mantha too much to trade for a big question mark and a first rounder that'll end up being late.