All depends on your forward depth and goaltending is horrible

IMO, no.

This core instantly looses because of goaltending. Schneider is playing in the freaking AHL and Jones barely has an 8.90 SV% on a team that should realistically be good

Not a chance. Without goal tending, you team isn't going anywhere this team is employing two of the worst statistically this year. Kind of hard for them to make a case that they would considering the rest of players on the team are good but not great players.

The offense would need to do some heavy lifting

If you're going to have those two goalies you'll need Rielly, Weber and Doughty

Or 3 stay at home defensemen for every pair