If Mete has a great season, puts up 25+ points, and proves he can play in the top 4, then maybe Detroit would do it. But as of right now, I don't think its enough to pry Mantha out of Detroit

MTL will never give mete

Yeah sorry not interested in giving up Mantha for Mete, Detroit's not giving up on him this soon.

Why would Montreal want another winger again?

this ain't it chief

to big , to slow ,turns over to many pucks and never hit 50 pts to date and DET fans want to sell him for the cost of a Seguin

Mantha's one of those guys the rule changes frigged over and its not to say he's not great now but 15 years ago he would have been a top RW in the NHL .
if he was a consistent 20 goals scorer maybe i'd be interested but Byron's more Physical ,more Responsible with the puck , Faster and is better for our system .

when your 6'5 guy throws less then 100 hits a year and your 5'9 guy with 100+ a year then there is something wrong with the Effort Mantha's putting in

Wings decline.

Big wings fan here. I would take this deal. I would rather see montreal send just a 1st rounder and take on one of our poor contracts. But still decent deal