Quoting: Breakaway
Right, but thats a gamble no player would take. I could see them taking 4 years because they'd make a lot more money, but if they can't take 4, it's pretty much going to be 8.
Matthews will get 11.5m-13m and Marner somewhere between 10M-11.5M. Matthews compares to McDavid and Marner to Patrick Kane. Adjust for inflation and cap going up and you're looking at probably having to do the higher end of those ranges. Kane and Toews didn't take any discount and Matthews and Marner are better players. If you think they'll take a discount because Toronto "needs them to" they should just turn around and say "well, I'm not taking a discount. If you're so worried about money why did you spend 11M on Tavares less than a year ago? Oh, you think you're giving him some of the money that should have been allotted to me? I'll hold out." If Marner and Matthews hold out Toronto would be one of the worst teams in the league so management would literally be bent over and forced to give in. The only way this doesn't happen is if Matthews and Marner decide to take team friendly deals to win, but that typically doesn't happen much so it's a long shot.
I agree with you regarding Matthews and I agree with
@Gauss that it will be a $20 MIL split. Where I disagree is Marner being worth so much. He is on pace for another typical 20 to 25 goals which he has done his whole career. His huge point total increase is his assists and playing with an elite super star line mate who has a current shooting percentage of 17.6 %. Put him back with Bozak and JVR then you would see Marner's point totals take a huge hit.
I am a Leaf fan so maybe I have a negative bias after seeing inflated contracts given to Phaneuf, Kessel, Clarkson, etc. I look at players like Gaudreau, Pastrnak, Sheifele, Monahan, Landeskog, MacKinnon at the $6 - $7 MIL window and would trade Marner for any of them 1 for 1. Hearing Marner being expected to make over $10 MIL sounds like Darren Dreger, Craig Button, etc or a horribly managed team like the Oilers not a successful GM like Yzerman, etc.