Top 5 Trelvings best and worst trades ever

The worst Trevling trade is giving a 1st round pick to give up on Monahan...........

You could argue the the trade was best he could do under the circumstances. But Trevling had put Flames in such a poor cap situation...that was the issue.
Just by going by the Flames record under Trevling. And his terrible resigning of Huberdeau to eight years. Why do ever get another GM job? Of course the Leafs have had a habit of signing poor GMs this century.

It was a bad but necessary forced trade, that's why I didn't include it in my list. Also we don't know if Mon will Draft a Nhl, Ahl or bust with the pick.

The Huby trade was a terrible trade from the start, he only made that move to buy himself time

He was forced to sign two guys to long-term deals who had both already peaked as a return for Tkachuck

The Lucic for Neal trade solved nothing for either team (not a win either)

Hamilton for those picks turned out to be fair value, those picks could have easily all been roster players and turned out bad for BT, he just got lucky that those picks were all busts

The Zadorov and SB deals were both good tho.

A lot of his "bad" trades aren't really his fault, you can't blame him that the other team made good selections with those picks either. That's out of his control entirely, the Elliot and Toffoli trades are hard to blame on him though the Hamonic one was downright disgusting from the start. The leafs picking him over Dubas may be the reason they don't win in the AM34 era

I guess I should do a Part 2 and look at Trev's best and worst signings.... Huberdeau makes the best trade list and worst signing lists...lol