Okay lets try Montour

I would take this deal.

Montour is a guy Kypreos and some media tried throwing in for every Nylander tried before they moved over to Manson when Montour was flipped to Buffalo. The issue is he did not do well in Buffalo, and their fans want him traded, that's why he's in every trade package. Either Friedman or Johnston (can't remember which one) mentioned that it seems like management is trying to move montour, that he likely won't be back next season.

Could the leafs use him, with our RD, sure it's possible, but I'd rather not take a 4M gamble on a player who has not seemed effective.

Connor Murphy is not a good defensemen. I see him lumped into so many trades, and the reason he's available too is because he is bad. He had a really good major junior career, and people still have hype for him because of it, but he is the opposite of what we need. He's a poor man's tyson barrie. He is a worst-case scenario acquisition if Rielly and Sandin got hurt kind of player.

I don't understand the obsession with Carter Rowney on here either, a 4C for a guy who (specifically when with Muzzin) made a formidable shutdown pair. I'm fine with Rowney, but he's a guy you trade like Calle Rosen and a 5th for, not Holl.

Otherwise, i'm fine with Boyle.Seems fair for Dermott and Mikheyev, although Nylander would not be 3RW, he's either top 6 or playing C.

I see so many Nylander and Marner trades, so it must mean they are terrible! That is the only reason why they would be in so many trades on this site!

No

I would never entertain moving Marner. If anyone is traded from the big 4 it’s Nylander. Not because he’s bad but because he can be used to get what the leafs need