Éditer l'avatar
  • png, jpeg
  • La grandeur minimale recommandée se veut de 800px par 800px
  • Grandeur maximale: 1MB
Glisser l'image pour repositionner
Sauvegarder
Annuler

Onslaught77

Membre depuis
5 fév 2019
Équipe préférée
Maple Leafs de Toronto
Messages dans les forums
491
Messages par jour
0.65
Sujets de discussion
35
Forum: Armchair-GM15 jan à 9 h 37
Sujet: well 14 day early deadline
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>MitchMarner_16</b></div><div>I haven't really seen anything from Roy or Holl that makes me think theyre worth much.

The biggest appeal to having roy, is that hes a capable bottom 4 dman, with a cap hit of only 700k. Holl is the same (skill wise), if not, a tad bit worse. However, the cap hits are what differentiate the values the most in my opinion.</div></div>

Because people hate solid defensive D. They want goals and think that defenceman should score 20+ goals a season and provide perfect D. In other words people have no idea what they are talking about. Holl has been very solid, plays the position properly and does his job the way it should be done. People don't pay attention to the stupid mistakes guys like Dermott make because they like him.
Forum: Armchair-GM 4 jan à 20 h 09
Sujet: If I was forced to trade from the top
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Penguins_Legend_Sheary</b></div><div>In hindsight, maybe the Leafs should’ve let Marner sit out the year &amp; walk away in free agency. They could’ve used the money to sign Taylor Hall to maybe 9-10 Million.</div></div>

Yeah. I like Marner I really do but he's replaceable on a core like this one. I get that fans love him and all but he's the only reasonable option to trade if you want to save AAV. Trading Nylander does nothing to save AAV and they can't trade JT nor would that make sense. A playmaker for JT can be slower, as long as they are skilled. All these people wanting the Leafs to trade because "you can't have that much tied up in 4 players" don't get that the only reasonable end to that argument is Marner playing elsewhere.
Forum: Armchair-GM 4 jan à 19 h 07
Sujet: Which Core Do You Prefer
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Brad21</b></div><div>Same here,but someone like my brother Saskleaf, or Steve Dangle would not.</div></div>

That's a different convo. If you ask me for the money if I would rather build a line around JT or Marner that's a tougher question. They are both valuable assets. I'm still not convinced Marner is an 11m player but he does have way more value than people think. Marner is younger but I think JT has more value in other areas to the team. Leadership, stability, work ethic, determination. The "fun" of some of the younger players is definitely part of the problem. I would probably say JT because Marner just doesn't play a proper game. He leaves guys wide open and doesn't watch his man. He puck chases constantly and just expects guys to clean up after him. He does the big things insanely well, like incredibly well but he doesn't even know the little things exist or that they are a thing. That's a big problem. On another team with more of a veteran presence that could be easily dealt with. I'm hoping that's what this year does.
That's why Keefe wants Jumbo on the top line.
Forum: Armchair-GM 4 jan à 18 h 51
Sujet: Which Core Do You Prefer
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>aadoyle</b></div><div>honestly I would rather have Nylander cause the funny thing is despite being called soft he is better at equal strength defense at (40%) compared to PLD at (25%). Thats surprised me considering Columbus is a defensively minded team. Only real advantage with PLD was his even strength offense at 94% compared to Nylanders 78%. That one bad year held Nylander away from being 90% at even strength offense lul.

Everything else was the same except Nylander was much better on the PP.

Now if PLD was better defensively and could PK would easily take him.</div></div>

Most people who want Nylander traded don't have a real reasoning behind it. That's why I made the Trading Nylander is stupid armchair. It doesn't accomplish anything. I said it before, with the current situation if the Leafs 100% had to make a big trade to save cap there's only one option. I don't agree that they have to do that but putting that aside if money needs to come off ask yourself what could the Leafs replace with a much cheaper option, still have great offensive production and for a much lower cap hit. Marner is the only option.
The Leafs can win without an 11 million dollar playmaker if they get a 6-7m one. Trading Nylander opens up a hole that uses up the cap space when you fill it. Trading Marner and putting someone making half as much in his place doesn't.
Forum: Armchair-GM 4 jan à 18 h 11
Sujet: My Top 10 LDs From 2010-2020
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Bcarlo25</b></div><div>Meh. A couple of these guys were really good for a window. I guess Vlasic did have a few really good years.

The guy that I’m really going to reject is Reilly. He had one awesome season. One.</div></div>

Reilly has been amazing playing with players who had no business on the top line. The best partner Reilly has had was Ron Hainsey. Morgan Reilly has been an amazing D-man and put up with being the only top D on the team period. The only way Reilly legitimately doesn't make this list is if you think Dmen shouldn't have any defensive skills period and they are just relocated forwards. He's been a defensive D when needed an offensive risk-taking D and excelled at it and made both work and has done both at various times. Without Reilly, the Leafs wouldn't be winning any games period. The only decent defenseman they would have had at all would have been Muzzin.

In my opinion, the fact that the Leafs have managed to get the wins they have and the playoff appearances they have is entirely Reilly and Andersen aside from their ability to generate offence. Without Reilly and Andersen the Leafs would have shown Detroit how to really be the worst team despite having the offence they do. Reilly absolutely should be on this list. If you don't get that your insane bias or you just know nothing about hockey. The Leafs complete inability to find a decent RHD until recently is a bad joke and has been the vast majority of their problem.