SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

MarcBergevin69

Marc Bergevin
Membre depuis
20 avr. 2021
Équipe favorite
Canadiens de Montréal
Messages dans les forums
641
Messages par jour
0.6
Forum: Armchair-GM17 déc. 2022 à 0 h 8
Sujet: habs future lineup
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>HeadHighSauce</b></div><div>absolutely. and I certainly don't want to be carrying Josh Anderson.

Playoff counting stats for Tatar:
TOI: 590 || Points: 12 || Shots: 65
Playoff counting stats for Anderson:
TOI: 652 || Points: 14 || Shots: 128

So Anderson isn't helping his team on the scoresheet anymore than Tatar.

How about on-ice results relative to their teammates:

Tatar -- RelTM G+-/60: 0.14 || RelTM C+-/60: 12.58 || RelTM xG+-/60: 0.2
Anderson -- RelTM G+-/60: -0.05 || RelTM C+-/60: -6.46 || RelTM xG+-/60: -0.36

So Anderson is a below average player relative to his teammates and Tatar isnt.

One more: Career playoff PDO
Tatar: 0.988
Anderson: 1.008

I'll take Tatar literally every single time.

I'm very excited for people to read this, have their eyes glaze over, and tell me "BUT TATAR WAS SCRATCHED" and "ANDERSON BRINGS A PHYSICAL ELEMENT YOU NEED IN THE PLAYOFFS". sigh.</div></div>

Why did both those teams scratched him if he is that good? Why would MTL scratch him over Jake Evans? Why not scratch Anderson instead?

Analytics are made so soft skilled players look good. They don't take the physical aspect of the game into consideration.

But everyone knows you don't need physical players in the playoffs because the games are softer. Right?
Forum: Armchair-GM19 mars 2022 à 12 h 19
Forum: Armchair-GM7 févr. 2022 à 15 h 23
Sujet: You gotta give to get
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Chrismurtagh</b></div><div>I know Theodore is worth way more. I just think if Vegas has the choice to either give up Dadonov and a second for nothing in return, Martinez and a second for nothing, or Theodore for a player and a pick, they may end up choosing to get rid of Theodore. If cap wasn't an issue it would take a tremendous price to get Theodore.</div></div>

There are teams who would trade for Martinez right now. Dadanov might need a sweetener simply to ensure no cap is coming back but my goodness, a 2nd round pick is wayyyy less hard to swallow than trading Theodore away just so you can get some value back.

Dadanov and a 2nd is not a big loss. Heck some teams may even send back a super cheap bottom 6 player to help fill the spot.
Forum: Armchair-GM28 janv. 2022 à 18 h 43
Forum: Armchair-GM24 janv. 2022 à 12 h 8
Sujet: habs deadline could look like this
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Xqb15a</b></div><div>You’re kidding yourself. Coleman and Pageau have multiple 20 goal seasons, Pageau 40 pts seasons. But hey leave it to MTL fans to take a piece of reporting by a reporter to hyper inflate their players value. And I’ll even give you credit, Goodrow isn’t better offensively I was influenced by his play with SJS against COL.</div></div>

LOL even with the 2 20 goal seasons that Coleman had he still doesn't put up much more offense than Lehkonen. I showed you above that over their careers they are within 0.05ppg which translates to 4 more points a season for Coleman over Lehkonen. Every player has up and down years, hence the reason we use career stats to compare players and PPG to compare value. We aren't comparing Lehkonen to Matthews here. You may have issue with Lehkonen cause you hate the Habs or whatever but the fact remains their career stats are directly comparable. BTW Pageau did not have multiple 20+ goal seasons he had a single 20 goal season. If you really want to get into the stats and use outlier stats to prove your point, I can flip that around and say that Lehkonen is more consistent than Pageau and Coleman in that his stats don't vary as much from year to year. Saying a guy like Pageau is more offensive based on 2 40 point seasons in an 11 year career is laughable those 2 seasons are outliers not the norm. Same as Coleman 2 out of 6 seasons he scored 20 goals again these seem to be the outlier not the norm, although with Coleman he is still young enough to make it the norm depending on how the rest of his career goes.
Forum: Armchair-GM23 janv. 2022 à 17 h 28
Sujet: Habs fans youll like this
1st trade - Montreal rejects. I feel like they could get Kravtsov for Lehkonen straight up. NYR aren't in a position of power here IMO. Kravtsov has made is publically clear he won't play in NYR (he went back to KHL because he doesn't want to play there). Lehkonen is an RFA so Montreal doesn't have to trade him. I think Montreal would consider Kravtsov + 2nd for Chiarot if that interests you. I think Kravtsov at this point is worth a 2nd IMO, so that would mean 2 2nds for Chiarot which is fair.

2nd Trade - I don't think Anaheim would have interest in this trade, and Montreal would be crazy not to accept it.

3rd Trade - Montreal rejects. Petry is worth more at this point to be a leader than that terrible package. Any trade with Petry starts with a 1st, otherwise we keep him.

4th Trade - I'm not sure why we are dumping Hoffman. He's a player who will thrive in an offensive system (like Hughes wants). It's not his fault he's a pure offensive player playing in a pure defensive system.

5th Trade - Fair value for Toffoli, I don't think Montreal wants to trade him though

6th Trade - At this point, I would probably do this deal, although I don't think Montreal should be dumping salary at this moment.