8 nov 2018
Canadiens de Montréal
Deuxième équipe préférée
Jets de Winnipeg
Messages dans les forums
Messages par jour
Sujets de discussion
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>tormundgiantsbane</b></div><div>Skjei is a... serviceable... defenseman. But when you watch him he's incredibly frustrating. He's been out no. 1 LD the past two seasons and having come in with the hype of "McDonagh 2.0" it has been frustrating to see him barely crack the surface of what McDonagh was at his age. Also, I'm pretty sure I remember Skjei being a healthy scratch fairly recently because he was struggling so hard (either way this season or sometime last season). Beyond that, we have unreal D prospects (K'Andre Miller, Nils Lundkvist) and young D (Adam Fox, Anthony DeAngelo, Ryan Lindgren), in addition to Trouba, so we really needed to trade someone eventually anyway. IMO, Skjei was the weakest link of them all. And an expensive one at that.</div></div>
Really surprised his value dropped that much. I would have been ready to outbid this by a mile, from a habs point of view, but I guess you watched him play more than I do.
No, I think Domi is untouchable at this point. Marc Bergevin is looking to build a team around character guys like him and Gallagher. And Montreal wants to make the playoffs this year so the return would have to help us now... Therefore, your protected list just doesn't make any sense.... We would also like to get one of your top players without giving any of our 10 best players. This is like saying we're interested in Ekhlom but we won't include Price, Weber, Petry, Kotkaniemi, Domi, Drouin, Gallagher, Tatar, Danault and Byron. <div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Billy739</b></div><div>Poehlings top 3 ahead of Suzuki for sure.
challenged on his skating year 1 , adjusts and fixes it
challenged on his Power and Strength year 2 , puts on 40lbs of muscle over the next year
challenged on his Stamina and Scoring in year 3 , he gets surgery after his tonsils come out because they found a flap of skin partially blocking his nasal canal .
Challenged this year on whether or not he'll be ready for a full 82 game season
he chooses not to take the summer off again this year to work on his preparations with Coach Olson in Minnisotta while playing in the DBL summer league with Pro NHL players .
the guys got a drive to him we rarely see
he's a pure Athlete with a chip on his shoulder and the drive to be the best his state produced .
Poehling's years ahead of Suzuki and even Kotkanemi for that matter who couldnt finish the year due to lack of conditioning and chose to take the summer off .
KK is a stud dont get me wrong , but Poehlings work ethic is Superior much like Rod the Bod Brind'Amour his conditioning is unmatched .
KK plays a Barkov style by his own words Draft Day and that takes time , Even Barkov took 4 years before hitting his stride as a complete all around All Star.
Poehling is on years 4 of preparing for the NHL on North American Ice so he's got a clear leg up on KK
Poehling might not win rookie of the year but he will be top 5 with his former teammate Jack Hughes IMO living in Hughes shadow the past few years and Clayton Keller's before that i suspect you see Poehling dominate the rookie race .</div></div>
I agree with everything you said about Poehling and I love him as much as you do but my ranking is about asset value and upside. I personally think Suzuki has a higher ceiling than Poehling even though Poehling is pretty much a sure thing at this point. KK is by far #1 in terms of asset value.
As for Brook, I doubt he'll be able to play LD in the NHL, as most D playing on their off side in junior end up switching back in the pros, but I would be more than happy if he can play LD. He would fill a huge need, sooner than our other LD prospects. I admit Fleury might be a bit low.
Hudon is done with the Canadiens. I don't see him playing one more game on this team and would definitely take a prospect like Hillis for him if the offer was presented. Wouldn't think about it one second. We have to stop thinking guys will keep getting better when they are 25 and still can't crack the line up. Other than that, I agree with all your other statements.