Quoting: Boltsbeathabs
This is 2 quality young players 6OA 3 seconds and this ACGM IS Utah going for a playoff spot thanks for your opinion but I disagree have a nice night
Again Toronto is win now. You are giving 0 pieces that help them win now. You need to give atleast one player that has good potential to contribute (Guenther, Doan, McBain), and/or you have to give someone that can contribute (Crouse, smaltz, durzi). Haydon is such a what if, and is seriously close to bust category. His value isn't where you think it is.
Thanks for the picks I agree it's good/fair value there but I don't think it out the Leafs in a better spot than they are now after this trade. They waste a year of AM34s window here. Honestly with the 6oa you could probably do Hayton and a guy from the second group I mentioned and they'd do it.
Generally for a superstar (see Eichel) you get atleast a 1st, a prospect, and a solid roster player. I understand you deviated here but the trade doesn't fit the Leafs needs, it's not a matter of fair value.
Have a good night, buddy!