Mock

Timmy Stu is the clear #1 here

Stutzle

Byfield
Jarvis
Faber
Sanderson

Raymond
Mercer
Peterka
--Lafreniere--
Zary
Lundell
Perfetti
Rossi
Holtz
Drysdale

Dude just stop. Raymond is clearly number 2. Now you're just starting to look bitter.

By every conceivable measure Raymond is second.

Raymond is just outside top-5.

What would I be bitter over?

Nope. Second and its not particularly close. We had this same conversation in the summer, you know, when you claimed Mercer was better. How'd that work out?

i've got no dog in this fight. i would definitely take sanderson over raymond. I'm not finding five guys i would take before him like the other poster, but definitely sanderson.

Sanderson has done nothing yet to indicate he's on the same level as Raymond. This list is about now, not what you think might happen in the future. Sanderson is a decent if ridiculously overpaid young defenseman with a lot of potential. Raymond is already one of the best young players in league. Hes first in u21 scoring in the NHL. Hell, hes got more goals and only 3 less points than Stutzle.

Sanderson is the more impactful hockey player right now.

Sorry, no. Raymond is driving play from the wing. Watch him. Sanderson is impactful for a team that got outshot 19 to 0 In the third last night. It's not close.

sheesh i wonder what team you're a fan of.

Being a Wings fan, I've often thought about what it would be like to have taken Sanderson. I think it's really close right now.

I honestly feel like you are low on Raymond.
You would take Jarvis over Mercer? I've actually been having that debate in my head right now over which one I would take.
Also Sanderson over Raymond is a debate in my head as well.