Eichel/Tkachuk didn't get anything close to this.

These are not close to equal

The classic problem with these posts as the values are all over the place. How does cozens power and a top ten pick equal wright tolvanen and two mid firsts?

The Buffalo one is the most ridiculous package imo, or maybe the jersey package of Bratt+Nemec+1st

I'd say Bratt>Cozens, Power=Nemec, Buff 1st>>>NJD 1st

eichel got a proven top six forward, a top prospect at the time, and 2 firsts while being injured. pettersson is more valuable than he was at this point. Tkachuk got a top 25ish player in the league at that point in huberdeau and a proven top pair defensemen. Tkachuk is a winger, pettersson is more valuable

Tuch was LEVELS below most of who you're asking for.

Krebs is LEVELS below most of who you're asking for

He only got 1 1st and a 2nd

Lol basically just every teams top 4 assets

Can he not pull a Tkachuk and just sign 1 Year arb deals till he's a UFA?

Your values are all over the map
Buffalo vs Boston values lol

You want Bostons spare parts for Petterson?

Trying to make sense of why Detroit would trade for a center and include Raymond/Edvinsson rather than one of Danielson or Kasper.

honestly did not mean to include the first, should be just cozens and power for pettersson

Which doesn't make sense for the Sabres

boston has very few pieces that would be of interest to vancouver. the buffalo deal should be just cozens and power

didn’t say that it would, a pettersson trade doesn’t make sense for almost every other team as well

danielson/kasper just don’t hold the same value as raymond/edvinsson

and pettersson is LEVELS above where eichel was when he was traded. petey is a borderline top ten player in the league, and will be coming off of back to back 100pt seasons providing very good defensive value as well. eichel was coming off of a very risky neck injury that could’ve caused his play to fall off. luckily for vegas, eichel is still very good

Especially not as guaranteed 3Cs for the next 10 years because you've got Pettersson and Larkin lol.

Ehh. Eichel's not really the best comparison considering his neck injury and his insisting on a surgery that was a relative unknown at that point.

He's the one who used it. Eichel also had term. Pettersson is a 1 year RFA

Boston accepts

rfa is not the same as ufa. also this is assuming petey comes with an extension

Yes a massive 12 mill+ extension.

For example on the NJD deal.

Nemec+Bratt at 9 mill+ we'll add UFA Hanifin at 7.5 for 16.5 mill

Or Pettersson at 12+4.5 mill to spend on 2 UFAs

I'd take Nemec+Bratt+Hanifin in a heartbeat let alone a 1st on top.

Also, you will NEVER get full value back trading a superstar.

certainly the worst offer for petey listed here but i couldn’t find anything else of value on boston

and he’s worth every penny?

He isn't worth it compared to things like Bratt+Nemec at 9 mill combined, Power+Cozens at 15 mill combined, Point at 9.5, etc etc

id argue that he is worth all of those. in order to get a top 8-12 player in the league you have to pay them accordingly. in the NJ case, having a one-two-three punch of hughes-pettersson-hischier is certainly worth giving up bratt and nemec.

It really isn't, at all.