That is a good offer for Gibby & Rico

I’d certainly think about it — wondering what the fellas takes are on it, joint effort time to accept or decline!

Would need retention on Gibson and take out Henrique and Mcleod (no need to get older and worse)

1st+3rd+Vanacek+Clarke for Gibson at 4 mill or even 4.5 mill

Why does Anaheim give you retention? They are already giving you 2 to 2.4 million of retention by taking Vanacek.

I’d keep Vanacek this year and dump him next to take out a 3rd.

My valuation is Gibson at 5-5.5 mill

Vanacek at 1.5-2 mill

The retention on Gibson is what gives him value. At 4 mill he has about 4-6 mill in surplus value (or a little more than a 1st)

Vanacek has about -3/4 mill

Overall paying for about 10 mill in surplus value. So a 1st 3rd prospecy

I would insist on switching the years of the picks -- we already have 3 2024 thirds. But I think that this offer is in the ballpark.

That's assuming that we're going to trade Gibby at all.