Value is fair for Guentzel. But if we use our cap space and trade our 1st and one of our best prospects on another winger, I will cry. Cowan and Minten will not be traded unless it's for a genuine star dman with term. Even then, they may not be traded. Wrong team for Guentzel.

Seeler trade is very reasonable. I can see the fit, but Philly is comfortably in a playoff spot right now. So they may not sell.

Easy pass for both sides in the first trade.
Leafs are not willing to trade Fraser Minton and their first round pick.
Penguins don’t want to trade Guentzel.
The second trade Leafs accept.

Pits will have to highly consider trading Guentzel at the deadline. This would be a very enticing offer. I think Pits accepts this but Leafs reject, based on them not needing another winger.

Pens are trying to contend. They won't be selling.

They might, and if offer for them would be like this, they definitely should.