So if I had to put a value on Guentzel it would be a 1st + an A prospect. Petterson would be the same. Retention is going to cost more (especially on Petterson who isn't a rental)

From what I saw, there were 2 young guys, two mid 20s, a 1st and a 3rd. Now I don't know prospects but let's say Nimela is an A prospect. Then the return is a slight overpay for one of either Guentzel or Petterson. The only interesting pieces are the 1st (which will be low) and Nimela.

So this trade would get one of them but certainly not both.

AZ is not trading either G, and has no want for sammie

No.

Wouldn't trade one of them for that package, let alone both WITH retention on each of them.

Pens can get far more trading Pety and Jake separately and with retention.

no

Pens and AZ both accept because Canada needs to win a Stanley Cup after 30 years.

Too bad tho that everyone in Canada outside Toronto will hate that!

If they do, the Leafs could package up Guentzel, Reilly and Matthews and send them to the Canucks so we can win instead.

Another massive overvalue of Leafs Scrubs and prospects