This isnt enough for Murphy, adding Dach wont be popular among Blackhawks fans. Especially for this return.

Murphy and Dach starts with a 1st, probably a 2nd as well, you can keep the mix mash of prospects.

If you need to move money to make the deal work Beauvillier/ Garland might work, but im not particularly excited about either guy.

Take Dach out and you got a deal.

Unlike other Hawks fans I actually really like this deal. A 2nd is around what Murphy is worth, Garland is a welcome addition to the top 6 and it fulfills his trade request, and the Brzustewicz for Dach swap gets the Hawks the RHD prospect they are severely lacking

I kind of agree, this is very intriguing. The only hesitancy I have is giving up Dach but getting a solid RHD prospect in Brzustewicz makes it easier to accept. The other thing is the Dach brothers have a tendency to get hurt, maybe we are selling high with him in this deal.

I think if Vancouver keeps Sassoon and ups the pick to a 1st rounder, I would be all over this.

I like the creativity, but not fond of either of these hawks players and certainly not including Hunter.

Yeah, I'm not sure who's over or underpaying. I'd say it's a little in favour of Chicago. Regardless I don't like the trade for the Canucks, they say no.