Quoting: Leafsfan98
No, it's not, you're asking for a better player, on a cheaper contract, a way better prospect, a cost effective RHD and 2 1sts
Go ask around (not Leafs fans of course lol) if they would rather have Tkachuk (just turned 24 y/o) at $8,205,714 x 5 years or 26 y/o Marner at $10,903,000 x 2 years. Many would rather have Tkachuk and it would be very close to the majority at least... so the comparison works.
- Rielly "cheaper contract" is because in your proposal you create 5 M$ of cap space. In my proposal, only 4.5 M$
- Reilly is NOT better than Chabot, according to raw stats, advanced stats and the hockey community...
- So you're saying Knies is a "
way better prospect" than Ridly Greig? ok lol they're the same age and Greig is already a 2-way monster
- Liljegren is a cost effective RHD, what would Pinto be you think? A cost effective C lol
- 2 firsts from Ottawa > 2 firsts from Toronto (for this season at least)
Quoting: Leafsfan98
I was proposing so much less value...
Of course, because you think
- Rielly > Chabot
- Knies >> Greig
- Liljegren > Pinto
- 2 firsts (TOR) = 2 firsts (OTT)
You're an insufferable homer (yet who calls others homers), so of course you think that lol
Quoting: Leafsfan98
Man, 12 PP points in 73 games is so much, just like 9 PP points in 82 the following season, or the 8 PP points after that, or the 5 after that... Then Phanuf gets traded and the Leafs become a playoff team and magically, Rielly has a .72 PPG... Definitely go with your logic where it came out of nowhere...
Rielly didn't have Matthews/Marner/Nylander/JT until 2016-17, 4 years after he was drafted... And come on dude, Kessel went from number 1 guy in TO to 3rd line in Pittsburgh, Kadri went from 1rst line in TO in 2015 to 3rd line in 2018... Bozak went from 2nd line in 2015 to 4rth line in 2018... Rielly's supporting cast from 2012-Matthews being drafted wasn't very good, they got the 1rst overall pick in fact...
As for Chabot, he had a competitive team around him, one that just made the ECF and added Matt Duchene, what happened? and weren't the Sens supposed to be comppettitive for 2-3 years now?
Stop trying to BS me BTW, the Sens had as many lottery picks while Chabot was with Ottawa as Toronto did while Rielly was in TO...
Damn, really have to explain every little thing
- It's not about 12 PPP in 73 games being a lot or not, it's in relation with the total points lol... 44% of his production on the PP, same with his first 50 pts season, 48% on the PP!
- oh yeah, Leafs became a playoffs team because trading Phaneuf unleashed the great Morgan Rielly and NOT because they added 3 young elite players... lol
- Rielly NEVER had a 0.72 PPG season... I mean you're not even capable of getting facts straight, what are you doing trying to argue with me? lol
- Rielly had 0.36 PPG the first season when the Leafs made the playoffs in 2016-17 You were probably not even old enough to follow so I actually know more about these Leafs teams than you do. Damn, you're funny kid, not every polite but funny
- Dear mother of... more inaccuracies... Chabot played ONE game in 2016-17, the last time the Sens made the playoffs. Yes he played with Duchene and company in 2017-18, but that was his 20 y/o rookie season... That team fell apart and was quickly dismantled by an owner who wanted to pay off his loan debt.
- As for the lottery picks or evenbeing competitive. Considering Sanderson, Stutzle and Greig are just 21 years old... no they weren't supposed to be competitive years ago... but it could have been better IF they weren't stuck with the worst GM/coaching combo in the league
- "lottery" picks : Tkachuk 4th OA, Stutzle 3rd OA, Sanderson 5th OA... Stutzle's pick was obtained by trading a 2 times Norris winner (now 3 times)