I don’t think either team would do that

I would take Carlsson, but I also think the Ducks need to add.

Curious why you prefer Carlsson? Consensus seems to be they are in the same tier, but if I had my choice I'd take Fantilli.

I think Carlsson has a considerably higher hockey IQ. I’m not saying Fantilli is a dumb player, but I do think his processor speed might lower his ceiling a bit more than Carlsson. Time will tell…

Interesting. I think I'd still prefer Fantilli

Don’t get me wrong, I would love both…I just think as players continue to get bigger and faster that processor speed gets more and more important! Also because I don’t think much of anything can be done to improve hockey sense…it’s innate, but skating can be improved on with practice.