No

John Gibson says no

Pat Verbeek says no

Insanity that you’re asking for retention on top of Gibson with that horrid return

Lol that's okay I don't care where the cat goes but if it's with an extension a first, 2/3rd round pick and a forward with potential... preferably top 9 ready is coming back

Has his value not plummeted over the last few years and he has lots of term to boot I can't see him fetching a whole lot

8-9 mil AAV for 27 goals. Good luck with that.

Verbeek has repeatedly said he's not shopping Gibson. That's not enough for Konecny either.

Well then I’m glad Verbeek said he isn’t trading him along with saying John doesn’t want to go anywhere so we’re fine

My favorite is when they say he doesn’t have value and stats are bad but are still trading for him — the CF Special 🤡

I'm getting Bertuzzi flashbacks. He sucks. He rental. But we'll take him for a turd sandwich!

Yeah it’s wild and honestly happens all the time

Have you looked at his stats? He sucks! Then check the lineup and they put _____ on their 1st line

So emotional lol you realize this is a site for acgm, we're not trading for keepsies haha... also I didnr say he was no good id love to add him but that doesn't mean his value is what it use to be

Can’t be emotional when it’s happened thousands of times my man

I know this site a lil more than you I’d say so yep I know what it is but thanks

Then we won't be putting him on the market, because we expect him to be our starting goalie for the next four seasons, which is incidentally why you're acquiring him. What other player on your roster do you expect to play for you for the next four seasons who would only be worth that $h!t return?

OTT declines DET trade, they will NEVER trade Cat to DET unless a massive overpay, and OTT will keep their best D prospect and 2nd best G prospect over a G that has sucked the last 4 years

I thought it was an overpay myself too lol bit apparently gibson is still considered elite around here

fans always think their players are untouchable or elite even when they are not.

Detroit passes, Berggren isn't available for Cat.

And all Canadian teams are on John Gibsons no trade list.

God forbid someone disagrees with you. We can't have that now can we? I guess you can always cry about it.

I mean what would Ducks fans know about Gibson? They've only watched every game of his NHL career.

Disagreeing is allowed on CFACGM.

Look in the mirror, Captain Hypocrite.

Simply put, Ducks fans are of the opinion that Gibson is still an elite level starting goalie. We watch him play, so we know he still passes the eye test. His stats are an indictment of the team in front of him, not a sign that his abilities have diminished. Compared to league average goaltending over the past four seasons, he has only been off by a couple of percentage points each year, the majority of which he had no goal support and a once great defensive core that was decaying in front of him, and by the time he had goal support, said defensive core had been dismantled.

There is a reason he was an all-star just last year, he rolled into the all star break with the Ducks in 2nd place in the division and him rocking a 0.924 SV% on the season at that time. After the break was when it was announced the team would be selling at the TDL, and everyone lost hope, and the team plummeted to 21st in the standings.

So, knowing that he can still play at an elite level, and having VERY recent evidence to back up our belief that he will return to said level as soon as we can put a defense in front of him that can fight it's way out of a wet paper bag, we see no reason to trade him period, let alone for a flamed out former 1st round pick, another nothing prospect, and a 7th, let alone retain for four year on top of that to boot. Even if we for some reason we're feeling that charitable, Gibson would block the trade himself.

If he's "not worth much" then we are more than happy to keep him on our roster through the end of his contract, four years from now.

You should read people's comments more closely. No one is rejecting the Gibson trade because we think that Gibson is elite; we are rejecting that offer because YOU think that he's good enough to be your starting goalie for the next four seasons and if so, that's a $h!t return.

biggest sens homer on the planet man

Yes, I wish all these trades would happen