Luke Schenn is a bottom pairing D-man. The whole reason why some Leafs fans want Holl gone is because 1) his costly mistakes (every Dman makes mistakes and if the team losses then it is costly), 2) he's viewed as being way out of his depth, he's playing 20 minutes, some view him was a 4th D others as a 5th, maybe even a 6th.

So paying more for Schenn won't make anyone happy. It's not a solution, nor is sitting Giordano.

The solution is Holl himself or Timmins.

I like Holl. Of course I also liked Ceci. They both played the toughest minutes where any mistake is costly, in the Leaf zone. They were both top pair PK and top pair defensive zone starts.
Addd in they are D all the way. You are not going to get any scoring from them. Just solid D minutes.

Muzzin played far worse last year than Holl and the media didn't say a word. He also coughed up the puck on the series winning goal. Not a peep. It is was Holl???

Holl and Ceci are both good D. Every D, every forward will cough up the puck at the worst times.

Schenn isn’t much better than Holl. Leafs may as well kick tires on Fabbro. Maybe Sandin a B prospect and a pick gets it done

Ceci was much worse than Holl. Still is

What has Fabro done that Sandin doesn't do? Fabbro isn't an no upgrade

Or you get someone better than Holl or Timmins. Who that is? No I have no idea.

GM likes Holl too much. I doubt he's traded.

Leafs left with 1 pick in this year's draft after getting knocked out by Tampa again. 🤭

he isnt better than holl

Tyler Myers? Kidding.

Unlikely, that they do unless they don't want to add up front.