Quoting: tonyhzs
11 is currently the magic number. He had 5 points across his first 5 games. He had two games with 3 points, for 11 points in 7 games. He is -11. He has 11 PP points. That's it for 11... but seriously 24 points in 40 games, but nearly half of those points come from the PP. And he only got 13 points across his other 33 games. For a guy who is playing 3rd line minutes, he needs to contribute more (and more consistently) to cover up the fact that he is not good defensively.
You might think I'm trolling here. I'm not. I've seen him play Detroit , and frankly, he is noticeable in the way that he looks out of place. Kubalik is streaky and not good defensively, but he makes up for it by putting up better numbers (30 points, 13 goals) . Kubalik is only minus 9, but splitting hairs there. Kubalik is streaky like Mittlestadt. Both players are similar in a lot of regards, Kubalik being a bit better. If Buffalo had Kubalik instead of Mittlestadt, and Kubalik was being traded in this proposal, I'd still say the same thing.
We all do it. We all like to overrate our bottom 6 guys. Fact is, Mittlestadt is bottom 6, and it won't matter what team he is on, he will be bottom 6 there too. He is an NHLer, sure. But bottom 6 guys have to figure something out, be good at something (usually defense roles or hardworking, but sometimes PP specialist). Mittlestadt doesn't have any tools to set himself apart from other bottom 6. He's ok, and that is ok, but these types of players carry little value, as they can often be found in free agency for cheap.
Getting 50points when playing in the bottom6 is VERY GOOD
Idc how/when the points come- it’s better than 90% of the other bottom6 players out there
Is he perfect? Of course not- that’s why he isn’t in the top6
Production counts though- & he produces
Even if it is inconsistent, it still adds up
And it adds up to him producing as one of the best 3rd liners in the league
Find all the reasons he’s not top6 & continue to spout them though, idc
If u don’t want him, that’s fine
But 50points on the 3rd line is VERY GOOD, no matter what other flaws he has