You aren't counting Robbie? Because he should probably be #1.
Amirov is really hard to access because of the whole brain cancer thing but the talent is evident at both ends of the ice.
Anyway don't sleep on Tverberg.

I hate rankings as tiers are much better so:

A:

A-: Robbie, Knies, Amirov*

B+: Minten, Niemela

B: Voit, Villeneuve, Tverberg

Rest

Knies under Robbie really?

Robertson isn’t calder eligible so technically not a prospect but he is often considered one. He has 16 total games in the NHL but because he played 6 games in 2020 then 10 in 2022, he is no longer technically a prospect. Tough situation as he is objectively their top prospect but technically not one at that.

Tbh knies is the second best one behind neimela but yeah any thoughts on 4-10

yes.



Yeah I wouldn't use those as your requirements if they are that strict, or at least create a mechanism for exceptions like this. Robbie is a prospect through and through

Nah dude knies>Robertson

The Robbie hate is approaching Liljegren levels, and the Knies hype train is getting a little ridiculous. Normalise for both of those things and Robbie should come out on top

I am just using things like that as a strict metric to avoid disparity between prospects and not prospects. Robertson is getting screwed there but at the same time it would also mean pinto is a prospect from the sens and he clearly would’ve played full time last season. Robertson got screwed by injury similar to pinto, although he’s technically not a prospect, he is still a really good young player.

Robbie would have been in the A most of last year. not comparable

Knies
Robertson
Niemela
Holmberg
Steeves
Abruzzese
Hirvonen
Voit
Tverberg
Peska

Can you give me some insight on holmberg, steeves, and tverberg please

This was from last year but he touches on all these guys

It’s finally here everyone, by far my biggest project: My #Leafs prospect rankings for Winter 2021Nearly 8000 words updating you on every prospect in the organization, from #1 through #34. Would really appreciate checking this one out and sharing 👇👇👇https://t.co/1RO23KurnW

— Kyle Cushman (@Kyle_Cush) December 16, 2021

Definitely looking into that, shouldn’t matter too much that it was last year as the only real addition to the top 10 imo is minten. Thank you!

1. Knies
2. Robertson
3. Niemela
4. Steeves
5. Douglas
6. Abruzzese
7. Holmberg
8. Voit
9. Tverberg
10. Hirvonen