idk man, monahan is less than useless at this point and tarasenko just had one of his best years. Any deal where calgary is getting vlad with 2m retention for monahan is going to have calgary adding a lot more than whats here imo

I hear ya in regards to Mony. Vlad and Mony are similar players imo, in that they both have prior injury history (shoulder for Vlad, hips for Mony) and if they're not scoring, they bring very little else to the table. STL is set to lose Vlad this offseason for nothing anyways as he is unlikely to re-sign there after requesting a trade. I just see it as a swap of similar players with some young NHL ready players going back to STL to sweeten the deal.

this isnt close whatsoever
take out the retention, its unrealistic, mony has almost no value atm, valimaki has no value either,
Dube is good but not enough for Tarasenko and scandella. Id say toffoli dube and a pick or prospect for tarasenko is much fairer

Is this satire?

This comment above: "Vlad and Mony are similar players imo, in that they both have prior injury history (shoulder for Vlad, hips for Mony) and if they're not scoring, they bring very little else to the table," has to be satire. This guy obviously doesn't watch Vladi play. He misses the fact that he's arguably a better passer than shooter, but his shot is so lethal, he's rightfully seen as a sniper. He's a bull with the puck and seldom gets knocked off it. He forechecks well for a sniper. When he came up, he couldn't play D, but he's sound defensively now. Geez, this HAS to be satire.

Uh monahan had a injury riddled year and close to no value at all. Tarasenko just had his best year. They are nowhere near close in value.