As the original poster that made the proposal, I would actually keep Roy over Doughty.
Its just we know Doughty wont be traded.

Well I’m sure u could find a team to trade for Durzi or Clarke if u wanted instead
Idk what to tell ya?
You’re the one who chose to move Roy in this ACGM, not me

I just think you’re overvaluing him a bit

One of Roy, Doughty, Durzi, Spence will have to go sooner than later unless they plan on carrying one spare forward and 2 spare dmen on the roster this year.
What would you do?
Also Faber and Grans but they wont have to be decided upon at the moment.

Yea maybe the value is a little high for Roy. Maybe one 2nd rounder instead of 2 makes more sense.
I dont know what Durzis value is but Im not opposed to moving him. Its early too to tell what hes worth.
Clarke isnt really available but if you want him itll cost a whole lot more than the Roy proposal.

YOU are the one moving out a RD
I’m ok not getting any of them
If the price is right, then sure, we’d be interested
But now that we’ve moved Dahlin to RD,
I don’t think the Sabres are desperate for a RD at all

Doughty, Faber, and Clarke are the defense of the future for LA.

Doughty will never be moved. He will retire in LA. Faber is Roy's replacement, Clarke is Walker/Durzi/Spence's replacement. Faber is the only two-way, defensively responsible defenseman in the pipeline. He plays the same game as Roy, but with more offensive upside. Walker, Durzi, Spence, Clarke, and Grans are all offense-first guys. The best of these guys will stick around for the long term.

If you're asking me which guy is going to be moved immediately, I'd say Walker is the most likely. Durzi will be the 3RD next season, and Spence will either be the #7 guy or play in Ontario (he's still waiver exempt). Once Clarke makes the jump to the NHL and gets some experience, then Durzi and Spence can be moved. Same goes with Faber to Roy.

Clarke is already signed and doubt hes going back to the OHL.
He cant play in the AHL.
Spence has proven all he can in the AHL and it would be pointless to send him down. But if they want to hang onto all the assets and not use some to address other parts of the lineup then it makes sense.

I'd put money down that Clarke plays in the OHL next season. I don't agree that it would be pointless for Spence to play in the AHL. He needs to work on his defensive game. He can go down there and play tougher defensive minutes and even get some time on the PK.