I think that’s too much for eichel take out rask and rossi then add greenway to the deal. You’d be able to buyout rask in that scenario and not give away rossi. Greenway being more expendable than rossi and the money works with buying out rask.

I don’t think you can get away with not sending one of Fiala, Boldy or Rossi tbh. If you put together a package that omits all 3, it gets beat pretty easily. I think even the package above gets beats, if I’m being honest. If BG managed to get Eichel without sending one of them, that’d be complete wizardry.

rask Fiala boldy/Rossi is good for Eichel.

Yeah, as I was reading it, I think your deal gets beat as-is too

That’s not what is being discussed. Neither my proposal nor the other guys comment suggest sending Fiala + Rossi or Boldy. I’d suggest re reading to see what we’re talking about.

Agreed. I think honestly there’s probably even several that beat it. This would be like 3rd or 4th best, it seems.

the flyers won't take this. Dumba is only signed for 2 more years. Patrick can be had, but not for himself and another 1st.

plus, isn't Minnesota looking for an impact player in the immediacy? Even if Patrick does turn things around and reach his potential; it won't be for at least another 3-4 years.

I flipped him as part of the Eichel package. Valuation with PHI I know is off. I’ve done several trades involving dumba and no matter what you do, it’s either MIN fans arguing dumba is worth more, or opposing fans saying he’s worth less. So I just put this in because it’s trendy and relatively non triggering on this site. I personally think if we got a 1st for Dumba, it would be a win.