Quoting: Stanley_Cup_To_Manhattan
Botterill and Murray had their highs and lows. Lack of success during long period of time was cutthroat for both. Murray made terrible draft selections and throw money out like candy. Botterill made some nice moves but drafting a bust in Mittelstadt as your first pick, trading O'Reilly for a box of cookies, Non-qualifing our only good goalie and getting nothing (Lehner), Getting bent in Skinner negotiations and basically outbidding himself, throwing draft picks away, and 3 years of no shown improvements got him sent off.
Well let's agree to disagree.
O'Reilly begged to be traded.
Did you ever listen to O'Reilly's entire interview?
https://thehockeywriters.com/sabres-oreilly-deserves-respect-not-accusations/
listen at 1:54, 3:00, 4:58 and 5:08 lost his love of the game. We were lucky to get a bucket of pucks after this interview.
He overpaid Skinner.
He never could get the #2 center, but maybe that was Cozens.
He never should have hired Krueger.
He made a simply horrible deal trading Scandella for Frolik. But I wonder if Krueger wanted that. Remember how Sobotka played on the second line? Frolik is another Sobotka.
I greatly improved the teams defense (only McCabe and Ristolainen were true NHL defensemen on the team Botterill inherited).
He improved the team depth.
BTW it is too early to call Mittelstadt a bust.
Only 8 players from that draft have more pts than he, oh yes he was drafted 8th and he is only 21.
Vanek, Pominville and Stafford did not play in the NHL until they were 21.
I do not remember anyone calling them busts.
The Sabres with Lehner, O'Reilly and Kane never had a winning season much less playoffs or Stanley Cup.
After finishing last in the Atlantic then last overall, Botterill decided to rebuild.
There were not many assets left after Murray gutted the prospect pool and traded away multiple picks for nothing.
I see no highs for Murray, just failure.
His team finished last in the NHL.
Botterill's teams were at least competitive for half the season, many times you must have felt really good about their chances of making the playoffs.
Did you ever get those warm fuzzies when O'Reilly was here?
I actually watched the Blues play, if O'Reilly played with that much intensity for the Sabres, we would have made the playoffs and he would not have been traded.
Let me close, I watched Sabres closely and the team always played better when the back up GK (look below at the backup records if you do not believe me) was in net while Lehner was here.
He had no value and signed for much less than a qualifying offer would have been.
He still has little value, as just this year he was traded for Martins Dzierkals then again for a fifth round pick.
2015-'16 Robin Lehner 5 9 5 39.5% Chad Johnson 22 16 4 58.5%
2016-'17 Robin Lehner 23 26 8 47.4% Anders Nilsson 10 10 4 50.0%
2017-'18 Robin Lehner 14 26 9 37.8% Chad Johnson 10 16 3 39.7%