Tyson Barrie is far too high and Morgan Rielly is way too low.

Matthews not 1st...

But last time I checked muzzin, Barrie, and holl all had better seasons than rielly this year. That Barrie is higher than rielly. Simple as that

Leafs are not taking away their most gritty player, Clifford.

Where the hell are you, “checking?”

Most impactful 5, in order: Andersen, Matthews, Muzzin, Tavares, Rielly

1st forward for sure

Rielly was playing injured.... and he was still better than Barrie. Think Sandin liljegren Dermott and in my opinion even Marincin should rank higher. Barrie was awful. He started to produce a bit more offensively in the second half but could still not defend.

My Ranking in Order is: Matthews, Andersen, Nylander, Marner, Tavares

Well I think Matthews is hands down the best player, I think given how sh*tty the D is, you need your G and two top D's to be on it. Goalies can singlehandedly make or break series', so Freddie is #1 no question for me. Next is the #1C, Matthews. Next is the shutdown D imo. Then your other #1C. Then your top all around D. As good as willy and Marner are, top wingers aren't usually as important as your top C's and D's and G

The shut down D pairing was muzzin holl so your ranking is Andersen, Mathews, muzzin, holl, Tavares,then rielly

I mean no like it's still more important that Rielly is the two way beast that he was last year than it is for Holl to be good. You get what I mean though