Zero reason AJ should be in the top 6 over Kap or Mange. Also that doesnt get Gaudreau

Just what the Leafs need, increasing their cap and trading a cost efficient RHD

Curious, how did Johnsson get the name mango... I’m assuming it’s him

That’s a garbage gaudreau trade flames would laugh at that then block the leafs number than die from laughter

Leafs dont do it either, makes no sense

Makes no sense to trade a bunch of garbage for an elite player? They could just flip gaudreau for a lot more than they payed if they can’t afford him

Top 4 defenseman, two top 6 forwards and a 2nd is a bunch of garbage? Enjoy losing the playin

Flames don’t need another top 4 defensmen you have valimaki scratched, also everyone else on this site thinks Kapanen is worth a 2nd and johnsson is worth a second. So a top 4 defensmen the flames don’t need and three second round picks found gaudreau? That is a horrible trade. Also enjoy never making it past the first round

Flames have won 1 series since 2009 and have a worse team than the Leafs now and for the future so don't know if you should be talking. And a top 4 dman and 2 top 6 forwards since actual NHL players are more impactful on a team like Calgary that needs them. Also, Flames aren't going to be getting as much for Gaudreau as all the fans like to think, hes gone in 2 years

Did you know that after a players contract is up they can sign a new one with the same team, I know it’s unbelievable but yes it is possible so I’m 2 years gaudreau can sign a new contract. Also that trade is worse then the hall trade and hall was only for half of the year

1967

I wouldn't be throwing stones from inside your glass house

...and no, the Flames aren't trading quality for quantity like the above proposal is doing. Keep you middling players or deal them elsewhere, they are not what the Flames need in return for their top offensive threat.

Pretty sure you brought up history first bud and 1 cup 30+ years ago isnt much better than the classic 1967 chirp. Just saying its not a terrible offer and Flames will end up keeping Gaudreau if they want much more (unless Chiarelli gets hired by the yotes)

Actually "bud" it wasn't me you were going back and forth with, it was someone else so I didn't bring anything up first.

Plus, you were the first one to throw a jab by saying "enjoy losing in the play in" to which the other poster said "enjoy never getting past the 1st round" which was totally fair because the Leafs haven't been out of the 1st round in like 17 years or something, so you shouldn't be flapping your lips about how far the Flames might or might not go...but then you doubled down by saying the Flames have won one series since 2009 which is hilarious because A) it's wrong, the Flames won their 1st round series in 2015, and B) like I just pointed out the Leafs haven't won a series since 2004, so that's when I told you to stop tossing stones from inside your glass house.

So try to keep up to the conversation next time "bud"


..and yes, the Flames will keep Gaudreau before trading him for a bunch of middling quantity. Players like the Leafs are giving up here can be acquired in other ways pretty easily, trading an elite talent for them is fools folly. That's what Sutter did when he dealt Phaneuf for a bunch of Leafs middling talent 10 years ago. Treliving won't make the same blunder.