Kane lol
Makar lolol
Carlson lolololol
Burns lmfao
Doughty is literally a bottom pairing d man
Rielly :toughscene:
Vasy lolol
Binnington way too high
Jarry...?
Price is an average starter (at best)

Gibson...? Stone...? Couts...? (Fox...?) McAvoy...? Spurgeon...?

Gibson over Raanta
Hamilton over Burns
Lehner over Jarry

The rest not bad

That’s pretty much what I thought too. Not sure why @AFOX10900 is this negative.

Carlson is the Norris winner or at least a top 3 finalist.
Kane 1.2 ppg is extremely elite
No need to criticize anymore. Solid points...... woof

You can tell you're a pens fan lmao

I literally had that typed.!!! Beat me to it. I was too busy correcting that afox guy.

AFOX10900 lulz, llololl, rofl
(sorry but this was an immature comment at best)

It’s weird not seeing the 9 time rocket winner on a top 10 list.

Unpopular opinion Zibanejad was a top 5 center this year. Also Stamkos was the 5th best center ppg above Matthews ....

Anybody with a Tom Wilson profile picture doesn't have a say.

All Oilers fans go tank a 1st overall

Matthews over Malkin
Eichel over Malkin
Kuemper Bishop Price Jarry what?
I don't see Josi or Karlsson that high
Doubt Doughty, Burns, Rielly make it in
Maybe Makar makes it in at 10?

No need to be defensive. Just a few minor corrections

both nearly as bad defensively as they are offensively, Kane more so

I mean I could have went through and said none of them are top 15ish players at their position...

Hughes, Slavin, Jones should all be in ahead of Karlsson, Letang, Burns, Doughty, Reilly

That would have sufficed.

Matthews is better than Stamer, but I certainly do agree Ovi is a top ten player. For some weird reason, people don’t like Ovi on this site.

Wow, this is bad.

I agree Matthews is better but stammer has a pretty great year

Yeah..... I’m still taking Carlson and Kane in my top 10. They are clearly elite. Carlson was on pace for 90 points for a defenseman. That’s impressive. Shouldn’t be this hard to understand but to each there own

Til points are a useless stat for d men

Makes sense. Every one of his 75 points were meaningless this season. None of those contributed to the capitals winning. I’d much rather him be a slightly better defender and score 30 points

nobody would, but I'd easily sacrifice 10% of the offense for average defense like most other guys who would be considered for top 10 d men

Oh man. Don’t feel like arguing but he’s a good to average defender and an elite offensive D man. Thee are many different ways to play defense. I feel there is bake in scoring

Imo defense is not letting your goalie face tons of high danger chances, and other shots, and Carlson is objectively terrible at that