Quoting: The_Real_FBGM_37
You really underate faulk
Quoting: Jangle29
That or hes an actual fan and knows him best
Quoting: The_Real_FBGM_37
Faulk for a 1st and a 4th is no good
Quoting: Jangle29
Thats more than they got for Skinner, I am no expert on Faulk but its clear hes not the most liked in the league as a top 4 dman if hes still there and they are willing to deal him. I could be wrong though
Quoting: Caniac2000
Faulk is an spare part which alone rn lowers his value, he's coming off one of the worst years of his career, and our best played got Pu back. I'm just trying to get somewhat fair value back
Quoting: Caniac2000
He's an offensive dynamo, he's arguably a 1RD because of his point production, he is nice to have on teams like these. He's still the extra D man in Carolina and that still means one of the 7 need to go, Faulk imo is the odd one out, with Pesce 1RD Hamilton 2RD Faulk won't like 3rd pair minutes and he won't wanna play LD
Quoting: Caniac2000
Yet there are strong rumours today Dubas called Waddell to ask about a RD....
Quoting: OilcountryGM
I think this is a large over value for Faulk, considering what the haul was for Skinner. I can't see any scenario where a team is giving up a 1st for him. Maybe a 2nd and a prospect
Quoting: BiscuitBakesandHotTaeks
Take bogo at half retention and it’s a deal for BUF
Quoting: OIlers4Life
Ill rate it a 5 just to level out his rating...value of faulk is accurate
I know it is hard to come up with one trade much less multiple for the same player. I will only speak to the Buffalo one. It is interesting that you used the picks the Sharks sent to Buffalo so this is easy. Projecting forward would you trade Evander Kane for Faulk and O'Reagan? I would keep Kane and not make that deal. But what do I know, I am only a casual observer and may be a bit biased, but I seriously doubt Betterall would make the trade you are proposing.