everyone is arguing about this but its so subjective. each person has their own perception of how good each player is, which means a player that is overrated according to one person may be underrated according to another person

ANA - Gibson // Manson
ARI - Fischer // Stepan
BOS - Rask // Carlo
BUF - Scandella // McCabe
CAL - Monahan // Brodie
CAR - Teravainen // Faulk
CHI - Hinostroza // Saad (a lot of options here)
COL - Kerfoot // Zadorov
CBJ - Dubois // Dubinsky
DAL - Janmark // Methot
DET - Bertuzzi // Green
EDM - Klefbom // Strome
FLA - Trocheck // Matheson
LAK - Carter // Martinez
MIN - Brodin // Niederreiter
MTL - Danault // Drouin (lots of options here too)
NSH - Arvidsson // Josi
NJD - Palmieri // Vatanen
NYI - Leddy // Bailey
NYR - Skjei // Shattenkirk
OTT - Ryan // Anderson
PHI - Konecny // Simmonds
PIT - Guentzel // Letang
SJS - Meier // Kane
STL - Schwartz // Bozak
TAM - Stralman // Gourde
TOR - Andersen // Reilly
VAN - Horvat // Gagner
VGK - Miller // Reaves
WAS - Vrana // Burakovsky
WPG - Lowry // Perreault

Woah....how is Manson overrated?!?!

He’s just a guy that I’ve never been that fond of. I’m sure Ducks fans can speak to this more than I can, but from the roughly 8 Ducks games I watch a season, I haven’t seen from him what I hear about him

Underrated/Overrated

ANA: Schenn/Lindholm
ARZ: Kuemper/Keller
BOS: McQuaid/McAvoy
BUF: Beaulieu/Eichel or Dahlin
CGY: Hamonic/Gaudreau
CAR: Di Giuseppe/Slavin
CHI: Murphy/Kane
COL: Wilson/MacKinnon
CBJ: Harrington/Panarin
DAL: Ritchie/Klingberg
EDM: Caggiula/McDavid
FLA: Haley/Barkov
LAK: Martinez/Kopitar
MIN: Rau/Staal
MTL: Alzner/Gallagher
NJD: Gabriel/Hall
NYI: Clutterbuck/Barzal
NYR: Beleskey/Skjei
OTT: Ceci/Karlsson
PHI: MacDonald/Couturier
PIT: Sheary/Crosby
STL: Nolan/Tarasenko
SJS: Martin's buyout fee/Couture
TBL: Coburn/Kucherov
TOR: Gardiner/Matthews
VAN: Eriksson/Boeser
VGK: Sbisa/Karlsson
WSH: Dowd/Ovechkin
WPG: Morrow/Laine

Underrated/Overrated

ANA: Schenn/Lindholm
ARZ: Kuemper/Keller
BOS: McQuaid/McAvoy
BUF: Beaulieu/Eichel or Dahlin
CGY: Hamonic/Gaudreau
CAR: Di Giuseppe/Slavin
CHI: Murphy/Kane
COL: Wilson/MacKinnon
CBJ: Harrington/Panarin
DAL: Ritchie/Klingberg
EDM: Caggiula/McDavid
FLA: Haley/Barkov
LAK: Martinez/Kopitar
MIN: Rau/Staal
MTL: Alzner/Gallagher
NJD: Gabriel/Hall
NYI: Clutterbuck/Barzal
NYR: Beleskey/Skjei
OTT: Ceci/Karlsson
PHI: MacDonald/Couturier
PIT: Sheary/Crosby
STL: Nolan/Tarasenko
SJS: Martin's buyout fee/Couture
TBL: Coburn/Kucherov
TOR: Gardiner/Matthews
VAN: Eriksson/Boeser
VGK: Sbisa/Karlsson
WSH: Dowd/Ovechkin
WPG: Morrow/Laine