Yay or Nay and Why

think that Seattle trade both say no

Zero chance the Flyers do that....it doesn't help us no or into the future.

why would fleyers want Brodie, an old 5mil expiring UFA?

Why would flyers want timmins, an offense only RD on his 4th team in 5 years? They have far better options in the AHL (Bonk, Attard, Helge, Samson).

Seeler gets at least a 3rd at TDL and walker probably at least a 2nd, (and probably close to two 3rds, a 4th and two 5ths collectively) What you've offered them has no interest now or moving forward.

I don't see Seattle giving up their top pair D-man for a second pairing D-man, a middle 6 winger that they have plenty of, and draft picks that are in the back half of each round, and won't be useful players for 2-3 years, minimum. (Not that I think Seattle scoffs at picks, they need all the help they can get to build their prospect pool, I just don't see it coming at the expense of their top pairing defenseman)