SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

OldmanWebber

Membre depuis
26 mai 2019
Équipe favorite
Canadiens de Montréal
Messages dans les forums
243
Messages par jour
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GM16 juill. 2020 à 15 h 23
Sujet: question to blues fan
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>BluesBandit</b></div><div>I’ll preface this with the fact that the scenario where we trade Dunn is less likely than us letting Petro walk. I think STL would want to move up in the draft to restock the prospect pool, but also a replacement. I’d propose, depending on who’s available at #9, Dunn, Blais, and our 2020 1st for Mete, Poehling and your 2020 1st.</div></div>

Montreal is not going to get pinched into overpaying to a team in cap hell. If you want our first you will need to pay, take out Blais whom we have zero need for and add Thomas, also add Allen and we will add an additional 2020 3rd (WSH) and Ylonen and just to even it out I would also send back your 2020 2nd(STL) ...so it would be Dunn + Thomas + Allen + 2020 1st(STL) for Mete + Poehling + Ylonen + 2020 1st (MTL) + 2020 2nd (STL) + 2020 3rd(WSH)
Forum: Armchair-GM7 juill. 2020 à 6 h 22
Sujet: 1 player from each of the 24 playoff teams challenge
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>draft_em_sign_em_trade_em</b></div><div>Not too excited about the goalie tandem, but a really good DCorps can fix meh goaltending. I've notice allot of people following this challenge seem to always take NYI's Barzal, what does that say about the rest of the Isles players. lol</div></div>

Yeah no big names with the Goaltending but Kuemper had great numbers this year. I figured the D could make up for any weakness. The original challenge that I saw stated that we were only suppose to use 4 ECL's I have seen a number of these with multiple ECL's but I followed the original rales, doing so you pretty much have to take Barzal and Makar, two great players and the best at their position still on an ECL IMO
Forum: Armchair-GM6 juill. 2020 à 15 h 30
Sujet: Hey DET fans what exactly is on the table
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Jo_Habs77</b></div><div>True.
But, I woud agree Mantha has way more to give than just points (Personnally I'd rather him over Larkin)
I would say MTL fans overvalue Domi greatly - I don't think he has a spot at centre on this team and I wouldn't blame DET fans for not being interested in him... remember he had his worst performances in that 4-0 sweep DET gave to MTL this past season...

It is interesting that DET fans seem to value KK the least? I'm guessing it's because we skipped on Zadina. But, KK had an excellent rookie season (better than Hughes and Kakko...) , playing as the youngest player in the league, then everything that could go wrong in 2019-2020 did; from his 16 pounds gained on his lanky build and his awkward camp, his early season concussion, to the spleen injury later on. He's played two seasons and he's still a teenager. He's already exceeded expectations when he was first drafted - I'm not the least bit worried.

Then, everyone seems to overvalue Caufield. He's got tremendous upside. But, he's a big wildcard, his one skill is shooting, if he can't translate that to the NHL, he'll be considered a bust.

Agreed, for this year's draft, they won't trade the 9th overall, goes without saying they won't trade the 1st.</div></div>

I don't see a long term fit for Domi either, he seems to be a better center than a winger and I would not keep him at center over Suzuki or KK, Danault is the question mark I guess, he is one of the most underrated two way players in the game but his offense is the weakest part of his game. Couple years from now he will be our 3C and with Poehling coming will we really need him? I still believe that KK has huge upside and would not trade him unless you have a true 1C coming back. I too worry about Caufield being a one trick pony. Time will tell I guess. All I'm really getting at here is that the ask for Mantha is way more than I would want to give up. The proposal you have above is an overpayment in my opinion, but often to get what you want and need especially in division you have to overpay.
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juill. 2020 à 18 h 51
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juill. 2020 à 17 h 35
Sujet: Thoughts
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>coga16</b></div><div>targeting Dunn is a good move, but like the Tampa guys, its goign to be hard to convince them to sign offsheets to leave cup contending teams. You are really going to have to over pay to get them to sign it since Teams if they know they cant make the cap work to sign them will trade them before those offer sheets chances roll in. They still want to compete now and are going to take guys on their ELCs vs future draft picks in massive overpayment offserheets.

Most guys wont really care about 500k-1m in a bump of aav in a salary of an offersheet to leave for a chance of winning the cup. But if you are talking about making 10m-12m over a long term deal, then you might catch their interest

Trading for him is far more likely than offersheeting Dunn IMO</div></div>

I also agree with the trade idea vs an offer sheet.
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juill. 2020 à 17 h 16
Sujet: Thoughts
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>coga16</b></div><div>big flaw in your plan, why would Dunn sign it in the first place.
Girard signed him 7year 5maav extension coming off a 23 point season. Dunn has simliar points in less games when girard signed that. Why would he ask for a lesser contract which he signs as an offersheet.

If you are goign to get him out of St Louis you are going to have to present an offsersheet beyond his market value and thats beyond 5m range</div></div>

I agree totally, and I also believe the thought process is right on here. We should target Dunn for sure but as you say the offer sheet is probably going to need to be 5.75 million per year on a 5 year deal. If they match they match if they don't we get a great young LD to play in out top pair right away not 2,3 or even 4 years from now.
Forum: Armchair-GM28 juin 2020 à 17 h 56
Sujet: IF montreal wins the draft lottery
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Ajp_18</b></div><div>Umm durability issues? Anderson has only missed more then 10 games injured once in his career and that was this year.

Value is determined on what people would be willing to pay for someone. Columbus doesn’t want to pay for what you’re offering and we don’t want to move what you want. So the value for Columbus isn’t even close. League wide it might be close, but for Columbus it’s really not, there’s no interest in what you’re giving us.</div></div>

I clearly stated that I understand that these two players are not what you are looking for, the point I was trying to make was you had said that it the trade wasn't even close.... I am saying the value is there...thats all