SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

LendMeYourMilk

Membre depuis
17 janv. 2023
Équipe favorite
Maple Leafs de Toronto
Messages dans les forums
20
Messages par jour
0.0
Forum: Armchair-GM5 févr. 2023 à 13 h 10
Sujet: Just trying things out
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Wadejos123</b></div><div>Hawks accept, but this is decently close to fair value imo. Mcabe w/o retention should get a 1st on his own, so with 50% retention (for 3 years!) he should bring in a haul. Lafferty is going to be a guy that brings in a much higher return than people think he will if he gets moved. Some of the big reporters like Serivelli are even starting report this. Hawks might be able to get a 2nd from a playoff team for Lafferty alone.

Value leans CHI's way but not by a ton I don't think. Depends how you value Kerfoot and Robertson though. Kerfott really isn't worth anything to CHI without flipping him and Robertson can't stay healthy</div></div>

It really all depends on how each GM views those prospects. You're looking at Robertson from the Hawks point of view...which is all fine and good. I doubt Kyle Dubas is willing to sell that low on Robertson. There's a lot of risk on Dubas's side because Robertson does have production on his resume. But he also does indeed have those injuries. All put together...It feels like one of those lose/lose situations. Robertson means more to the Leafs than to any other fan base.

To me Fraser Minten is still a complete unknown. He's the #3C on a team that's going ALL IN trying to win the WHL this year trading away (4) 1st round picks for Zellweger/Hofer. He's played some #1LW with Stank, but the question is still...Is Minten's production because he's really good? Or is in because he's simply not the focus of the opponent? Logan Stankoven is the main focal point. This to me is another prospect that means more to TOR than to an acquiring team.

Let's take the counter argument. Frank Nazar. He's been hurt all year. Do you think another team would trade the #14 OA pick straight up for Nazar? It's all hypothetical, but I don't think another team would take that chance.
Forum: Armchair-GM5 févr. 2023 à 11 h 34
Sujet: Just trying things out
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>exo2769</b></div><div>Hawks absolutely say yes. It's quite frankly too much. McCabe 50% retained isn't nothing, but this is a lot.</div></div>

Hawks accept, but this is decently close to fair value imo. Mcabe w/o retention should get a 1st on his own, so with 50% retention (for 3 years!) he should bring in a haul. Lafferty is going to be a guy that brings in a much higher return than people think he will if he gets moved. Some of the big reporters like Serivelli are even starting report this. Hawks might be able to get a 2nd from a playoff team for Lafferty alone.

Value leans CHI's way but not by a ton I don't think. Depends how you value Kerfoot and Robertson though. Kerfott really isn't worth anything to CHI without flipping him and Robertson can't stay healthy
Forum: Trade Machine Proposals1 févr. 2023 à 23 h 55
Forum: Armchair-GM1 févr. 2023 à 23 h 24
Sujet: Scoring And Goalie Adds
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>aadoyle</b></div><div>Demko has been awful this year. I think last year was an outlier. He had the same bad defense last year and did well, cant use the same excuse this year.

Its not like Hellybuyck who can win the Vezina with an AHL dcore</div></div>

So 100 games of elite play is more of an outlier than 15 games of bad play this season? That doesn't exactly make sense. Wouldn't THIS season be the outlier? Also, you are wrong about the defense. Statistically, the defense were all overperforming last season if that is even possible. Hughes is worse defensively this season, OEL and Myers are MUCH worse defensively compared to last year. Both had "not terrible" years last year. It is completely different this year. Canucks had the 8th fewest goals against last season. That "same defense" doesn't turn the team into a bottom 3 team in terms of goals against
Forum: Armchair-GM2 févr. 2023 à 14 h 16
Forum: Armchair-GM2 févr. 2023 à 18 h 13
Sujet: Dubas Fights for His Job
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>JaredOfLondon</b></div><div>well to start, Hughes and demko arnt nearly that good. Like, there are over the top takes and there are those. Hughes isnt even a top 15 d-man in the western conference and Demko has two decent seasons and two bad ones and is hurt, at this point he's not even an upgrade on the guys the leafs got out of the scrap bin last summer.
Boeser doesnt have great value and Garland is having such a good season there is rumours he's going to be bought out, and 7th defenders like schenn are not valuable at all.
And as I said before, retention does not magically make a player more valuable as the cost of the retention needs to be worth it, and in this case it certainly is not.</div></div>

Try and name me 15 better dmen than Hughes in the western conference. You can’t. He may not be great defensively, but he’s improved and is not a liability in his own end like Barrie/Rielly/Karlsson

Demko was elite last season, borderline elite the season before, and had 15 bad games due to injury/terrible dcore/historically bad PK

Boeser at full salary doesn’t have much value, but at half retained he does. Garland he had a tough season, but I don’t believe the buyout rumours at all. I expect him to bounce back under Tocchet