Quoting: Warpbox
Just this once I will argue this:
Elias Pettersson had a down season. With that down year Sebastian Aho had slightly better production. If you want to argue Aho had the better season that would be fair, but that does not account for Petterssons injury in the second half. Even factoring that in Elias Pettersson has been: More overall productive (83 point pace vs 97 point pace) a *slightly* worse goal scorer (36 goal pace vs 37) set up way more goals (46 assist pace vs 61 assist pace) the better even strength producer (68 point pace vs 55 point pace) even strength scorer (30 goal pace vs 27 goal pace) even strength playmaker (38 assist pace vs 28 assist pace) and has a *slightly* lower xGA on 5-5 (2.401 vs 2.469 xGA per 60) as of natural stat trick)
As far as line mates go for this season where they were pretty similar overall (Aho was better though) Aho played with (at 5-5) Jarvis, Teravainen, Slavin, and Svechnikov primarily. Pettersson's primary line mates were Hughes, Mikheyev, Hronek, and Hollander. Hughes is obviously the best player on this list but overall Aho easily played with better line mates. In summary, Elias Pettersson when healthy is way better then Sebastion Aho
This is extremely disingenuous. EP40 has had one season where he outproduced Aho, and he does that will spending large portions of the season with Miller and Boeser. One thing about Aho is that his linemates have been in a blender his entire career. EP40 had way more consistency because Vancouver don't chop and change as much because they have a line that can score when it needs to with him, Miller, and Boeser.
You then mention EP40's injury, which is fair. However, Aho was playing hurt this season too. That game in Vancouver, ironically, that sparked the Canes team meeting that turned the season around? Aho was still dealing with side affects from the injury that knocked him out in October. And then, when moving onto the linemates, you say Aho's are better overall while Jarvis played the entire year with a torn rotator cuff and torn labrum, then played with a broken finger, Teuvo's hand doesn't close properly after a slash from JG Pageau so he's not nearly the player he was, and Svechnikov missed half the year. Slavin was healthy, and is the best teammate on either list, but he's not an offensively gifted player. Compare that to Hughes, Hronek, Miller, Boeser, Hoglander, and even Lindholm who EP40 played a lot with towards the end of the year on the Vancouver powerplay, and it becomes clear EP40 has way more to work with offensively.
If we then compare them defensively, this is a mismatch. Aho's GA/60 is 1.73. Pettersson's is 2.59, according to NST. Pettersson's isn't even bad, but that's a brutal mismatch. Given that Aho has that defensive credibility EP doesn't right now, he's outproduced him in almost every season, and he tends to do it with inconsistent linemates, I just don't see the debate here. It's Aho, and I think there's a gulf in class here. Especially if you then factor in their playoff performances, where Aho was a PPG. I thank you for at least using stats and facts to discuss this with me, as opposed to resulting to insults, but it seems we're going to agree to disagree here