campbell alone would cost more than 2 1st for the penguins to take.

No chance Calgary sends Tanev to the oilers for that.

Need alot more for Pittsburgh to take that deal. Guentzel alone is worth that, nevermind taking back Campbell

I feel like a lot of Pens fans really overvalue two or three months of Guentzel, and also undervalue the benefits of just getting a deal done, and further undervalue the benefits of using his value to move extra cap space out the door.

The Tane trade needs a 1st but IDK if Edmonton does that (they should tho).

It's not Pens fans overvaluing Guentzel, it's just what the market has historically paid for the top rental at deadline day.

Guentzel will go for a first plus if he is moved.

Taking Campbell and Foegles salary is easily another 1st plus in compensation.
Additional 3M retention would be another 2nd at minimum.
Tanev is possibly a first as well if not a 2nd and good prospect.