Same ole boring copy and paste goalie trades. So you want the devils to rush a cup? that what is gonna happen when you get helly cuz he isnt getting extended. Can we just move on to something CREATIVE. Window just opened everyone else CLOSE THE WINDOW DEVILS RUSH THE CUP

Devils decline. To even consider trading Holtz it has to be one for one

What are the devils giving up in that trade that closes the window??

SOOOOOO far off on Dobson alone bro what.

If hes your teams #1 RD immediately, why would we give him up for crap? This isnt EA franchise mode where 3 C pieces and a 1st get you an elite level player

Yeah one of the best defensive metric rhd in the league and a great middle 6 forward are crap both with 50% retention, at least know what you're talking about if you want to object to the trade

Let's completely ignore the fact that those said players are 30+ making them C pieces. at least know what you're talking about if you want to object to the trade

LOL yeah not how value works bud 😂 and I never objected to the trade, try a coherent response next time

Middle six forward? We have 10 of those we dont need him.

Demelo? Okay hes good, hes also 30 and has no offense.

Dobson is a premium young RD with two way abilities. Hes the most valuable position in hockey right now. And thats why you want him.

Three mid pieces dont do anything. Demelo is replaceable. The same reasons you do this are the EXACT reasons we do not. If demelo is so good, keep him

you know im right too

very tiny minded of you to think that being 30+ doesn't effect value

Flyers say no to TK deal, Holtz is cool but I'd rather keep TK

I would also say they probably say no on the Stanley deal because they have so many defensemen already, but who knows? 6'6" and Torts is a match made in heaven

Agreed they would decline both

its definitely how value works. young RHD who produce at a high level are one of the most valuable assets in the NHL. Demelo on his own even with retention is a 2nd at best, same thing with Nino.

If you think a mid-late 1st and two 2nds is enough to get Dobson you're out of your mind lol

Never stated that it was a good deal for the Islanders, I said they're not C pieces and being 30 is not the same as being 35

The fact that they both have 1 year remaining on their deals as well as being 30 definitely makes them around C pieces , give or take. Especially in an offseason trade.