Not getting our #1 DMan for that.

CGY shouldn't pay that price for Leddy. That's a 1st round pick + a first rounder (Lazar) + a 2nd rounder (Kylington).....Kylington has more upside than Lazar, likely, and that package, even adjusted to current value for Lazar and Kylington is still a 1st and two 2nd round picks. Not worth it for CGY, and apparently not enough for NYI.

This is perfect. Considering we've now got a NYI fan saying its not enough (home team typically overvalues their players) and a CGY fan saying its too much (typically does the same), I'd say the value is pretty realistic. This would be a package similar to what CGY gave up for Hamilton (1st and 2 2nds) which I would be prepared to do, especially for a Defenseman of Leddy's calibre locked in for 5 years. I think NYI's desperation and need to move a contract could make this trade viable. Hamonic's contract is much better, so I could see them keeping him around. I'm sure NYI would rather move Boychuck but Leddy is more moveable. I could see CGY sweetening the pot a bit, but overall, the 1st rounder, plus Kylington, plus Lazar thrown in, seems like a fair deal to me for a Top-2 defenseman from a team in salary cap trouble. I think these comments prove that.

Not saying value isn't there, Leddy just wouldn't be available.