Sandin should make matthews money

Hahaha that’s awesome.

And for the poster, definitely an interesting take. Can’t say I have a lot to argue about. Except maybe Matthews at 16 mil. But I get it.

I disagree on quite a few of your evaluations:

1) Matthews is amazing, and is worth $12.5-$13.5 million. If the cap jumps up by $10 million or so, then I could see him being paid upwards of that, but not now with the flat cap.
2) Marner is worth $10.5-$11 million easily. He's always above a PPG, plays great 5 on 5, the top powerplay, and also kills penalties.
3) Tavares is still a PPG player, and is fairly good defensively. He's probably worth in the range of $8-$9 million on a lot of teams (provided they would have the cap space).
4) It's hard to give a fair value to Matt Murray due to his health problems the past few years, but a conservative guess would have his worth around $2.5 million dollars, as he has a history of doing well in the past, and looked good at the end of last season.
5) Close on Bunting, but he's probably worth the same amount as Hyman, around $5.5 million.
6) After the season he had last year, I'd say Engvall is worth every dollar his contract is at right now.
7) Muzzin has had health issues, but since being acquired he's arguably been our best defender. He's worth at least $5 million for sure.
8) Kerfoot at $2.5 million is insulting. He's s 50 point scorer, excellent defensively, plays both power play and penalty kill. I'd say at $3.5 million he's actually undervalued as to what he'd be worth on the open market (assuming their wasn't a flat cap that is).
9) Sandin is worth just as much as Liljegren, if not more. Closer to $2.5-$3 million I'd say.

I mostly tend to agree except I think bunting and liljegren are worth more and Reilly and Tavares are worth less.

Seeing what Kadri just signed for is say that’s probably what Tavares is worth. Very close.

Rielly probably worth Krug/pulock/Ellis/eckholm type money.

Liljegren could easily be worth 4+ as soon as this coming year.

Bunting imo is worth close to $6 million. Maybe something like what mangiapane just signed for

You have a 22 man roster. why don't you have 22 salaries?