I think you should get a Marner jersey, guy is super slick, with a great set of wheels, and an unbelievable wrist shot release. #16

Matthews, Marner, or Rielly. 3 least likely guys to get traded. I agree with Zach, go with Marner. Sooo much fun to watch.

My first thought is that it doesn't matter, as long as it's not a Toronto jersey.
My second thought is a Reimer one, with Reimer scratched off and Bernier below it, and Bernier scratched off and Andersen below that, and Andersen scratched off with a big "?" below that.
Seriously though, for longevity, you're probably best off with Matthews. He's the only player likely to be completely untouchable for several years.

I hope you can afford more than one sweater. I'd say Marner being a Toronto area boy, might stay in Toronto for his career. But the Leafs likely will have Marner,Nylander and Matthews for all or almost all their years till they are UFAs.

I'd go with #16 you can't go wrong with a super skilled player like that he is probably in a few years going to be this generations Gilmour. But your roster has a few issues. Zaitsev is probably going be north of 4 Million and Hyman and Brown are not going to sign that long for that cap hit.