You didn't post a trade.

Not sure why it doesnt show. I edited it back in.

I think that the minimum we would accept for Gibson is Guentzel, Marino and your 2021 first, which you don't have. Maybe Poulin and Legare would substitute.

None of the pieces in your trade other than Poulin (with the possible exception of Jarry as a temporary but inadequate replacement for Gibson) interest us.

That is an outrageous ask. Guentzel, imo at least, has quite a bit more value than Gibby alone. Marino has had a rough start to the season but is still projected as a long term solution for Pittsburgh's top pair RD.

Franchise players are franchise players. The fact that franchise goalies almost never get traded isn't an accident. What do you think that Tampa would ask for Andrei Vassilevskiy? And he is 50% more expensive. What do you think Winnipeg would ask for Connor Hellebuyck?

This idea that franchise goalies don't merit high returns arises out of the idea that franchise goalies aren't much different from run-of-the-mill netminders, and frequently surfaces in comments like "They would be lucky to get a first and a decent goalie prospect" for someone like John Gibson. If that were true, guys like Jordan Binnington and Darcy Kuemper and Carter Hart would be flying around the NHL like seagulls at the beach.

I dont disagree, but asking for a top 10 left winger in the nhl and a stud young top 4 D signed to reasonable term is a non starter for really any team id think.

. . . and more. And that's exactly why franchise goalies never get traded. The idea (not yours) that Darcy Kuemper's price would be lower than Jason Zucker's or Kasperi Kapanen's is ridiculous.