Yeah.... just no...

Why no?

Every single one of those trades are unrealistic and would never happen.

What about now?

Murray + 1st > Fluery + 4th
Guds is not worth a 2nd and 6th, maybe a 3rd at BEST, realistically probably a 4th or 5th

Still doesn't fix JR's mistakes though... we still have Tanev signed for too much too long, JJ, the Brassard fiasco, trading for Reaves, etc

I know I will be bashed for this but the Penguins kept the right goalie

It's fine we all have opinions, but Murray is always getting injured and letting his personal problems get in the way of his job. He also has good defense playing in front of him.

The acquisition of Brassard was a great move on paper. It didn't work out, but I won't say that was a Rutherford mistake either. And getting McCann and Bjugstad back in the deal to send him out was pretty good too. I agree with everything else you said though.

You can make criticisms for both goalies but I would just trust Murray more in big games. And I just think that in that situation you keep the younger goalie who has proven himself. Would've been nice to keep both though.

I think that the GM can choose to pay money to be exempt from the draft

In 6 years Murray will be better

Pekka Rinne vs Matt Murray
Who is better?

Rinne. In a few years Murray will be better

What about this
Juuse Saros vs Matt Murray
A

Saros ? I'm a little biased though

Are you a preds fan?

No. I don't like Murray. He is my least favorite goalie. With Saros, I prefer Short goalies.

Oh okay that makes sense. Preds are my team and Murray is my least favorite too

Moving Fleury was not a mistake and is the right move 10 out of 10 times (and I am not a Murray fan).

Reaves was a Lemieux move, so point your finger where it belongs.

Brassard should have been a great get. No one could have predicted that he would mentally break.

Gudbranson wouldn’t have been needed if Sullivan didn't bench anyone that showed any spine. Same goes for Tanev.

When Crosby comes in and requests that you help one of his buds, Johnson gets signed.

Ahhhh, Jim you've spoiled us with so many blunders