From a MTL POV, I think this is fair value for Patches.
Not sure why CHI would give up on Rutta and Manning.

The only senario I give up Beaudin is if Patches agrees to an extension with Chicago, but MTL retains half the value of his contract before sending him our way. I don’t want to give up Beaudin, our LHD prospects are a bit lacking and he is interesting at the very least. I know that is an unrealistic ask, but we don’t want patches at the cost of futures unless it’s a really good deal.