Please no.

Pretty even trade I'd say

I would certainly consider this. When you factor in that Dumba is likey re-signed to a lower cap hit than Nylander, and would fill a big hole at RHD...it's something to explore

When you look at realistic options for the Leafs top pair RHD via trade its probably Faulk, Dumba, Parayko, Manson etc. (in no particular order) IMO Nylander will more than likely be in the deal if they manage to get one of those players. I could see some type of deal like this happening with probably an asset or two for each sides added to the mix.