I put math in hockey
Rejoint: juin 2018
Messages: 624
Mentions "j'aime": 167
How to lose your young core by signing massive deals to players nearing the end of their prime 101. The issues:
1. You have just over 1 million in cap space. You get 12 million relief from UFAs. Some will need resigning/replacements. You get maybe 2 million extra space. There is no way to keep Doughty without losing Marner/Matthews. So, you either traded Gardiner+ for 1 year of Doughty or you traded Gardiner + Marner/Matthews for Doughty. Neither of those are good. And the chances are decent that Doughty will demand enough that you can't keep either of Marner + Matthews with him. This is bad.
2. John Carlson is a great offensive #1D and strong powerplay quarterback. So is Gardiner. So arguably is Rielly. Carlson is not the best answer at 1RD, especially given how much term and cash he commands.
3. Tavares is great, but his term and cash are issues, and TOR isn't desperate for a centre. Why bet so much on him?
Ultimately, this is arguably the best lineup the Leafs could ice next year. It also shortens their window by about 5 years. I'll take the extra 5 years of championship window over the superteam today any day.