Build the muscle around the kids

an argument from PIT.
Would have accepted Bahl 1 for 1

no bah 1 on 1 is not enough

this trade here is also too much

jarry for this year 1st and we have a deal

Tristan Jarry does not return the largest goalie package of the salary cap era.

you are expecting to much out of a goalie trade. They are not going to get a 1st out of him.
Rather than get a second Bahl coming back is a guy they can at least use in their 3rd pairing.
The 2nd round pick, that won't see the ice till Crosby is retired. At that point, who cares.

clearly your reasoning works but... bahl is not as valuable as a 1st/2nd round pick imo, he is not that good. we need a top 4 LD from a jarry trade or at least gain the assets to go trade for him.